| Rev. Charles M. Browne |
1882 - 1886 |
Gardiner |
| Rev. J. L. Hoey |
1886 - 1888 |
Gardiner |
| Rev. J. L. Hoey |
1888 - 1892 |
Milton |
| Rev. Bernard Duffy |
1892 - 1894 |
Gardiner |
| Rev. John B. McGrath |
1894 - 1899 |
Gardiner |
| Rev. John J. Morris |
1899 - 1905 |
Gardiner |
| Rev. William J. Stewart |
1905 - 1909 |
Gardiner |
| Rev. John B. McHugh (interim) |
Summer of 1909 |
Gardiner |
| Rev. James A. Brady |
1909 - 1914 |
Gardiner |
| Rev. John J. Hopkins |
1914 - 1922 |
Gardiner |
| Rev. Harry F. Curtin |
1922 - 1924 |
Gardiner |
| Rev. William Humphrey |
1924 - 1929 |
Gardiner |
| Rev. William Humphrey |
1929 - 1934 |
New Paltz |
| Rev. Christopher McCann |
1934 - 1944 |
New Paltz |
| Rev. George B. Fagan |
1944 - 1949 |
New Paltz |
| Rev. John H. Mahoney |
1949 - 1955 |
New Paltz |
| Rt. Rev. Msgr. Edward P. Monckton |
1960 - 1970 |
New Paltz |
| Rev. Msgr. John Mulroy |
1970 - 1975 |
New Paltz |
| Rev. Peter Damian Preziosi, O.F.M.
Cap. |
1975 - 1977 |
New Paltz |
| Rev. Joseph Testagrossa, O.F.M.
Cap. |
1977 - 1984 |
New Paltz |
| Rev. Raphael Iannone, O.F.M. Cap. |
1984 - 1990 |
New Paltz |
| Rev. William Shannon, O.F.M. Cap. |
1990 - 1996 |
New Paltz |
| Rev. Michael Banks, O.F.M. Cap. |
1996 - 1999 |
New Paltz |
| Rev. Maurice Moreau, O.F.M. Cap. |
1999 - Present |
New Paltz |